Skip to main content

Fall Pre-Order
Pop-Up at May’s

Pastries and Savories

Cookies, Bars, and Cake

Muffins, Scones and Biscuits

  • Filters Sort results
    Reset Apply
    Name
    Price
    Quantity
    Add to cart
    $36.00
    Max:
    Min: 1
    Step: 1
    $34.00
    Max:
    Min: 1
    Step: 1
    $34.00
    Max:
    Min: 1
    Step: 1
    $33.00
    Max:
    Min: 1
    Step: 1
    $34.00
    Max:
    Min: 1
    Step: 1
    $15.00
    Max:
    Min: 1
    Step: 1
    $11.95
    Max:
    Min: 1
    Step: 1
    $5.95
    Max:
    Min: 1
    Step: 1
    $13.95
    Max:
    Min: 1
    Step: 1
    $15.95
    Max:
    Min: 1
    Step: 1
    $41.00
    Max:
    Min: 1
    Step: 1

Fall Pre-Order and Pop Up

Our favorite time of year is here—cool air, cozy flavors, and golden, buttery crusts. Join us for Flaky Tops & Cozy Pots, a limited-time fall celebration featuring our signature pies, pastries, and savory pot pies.

Pre-Order Details

Skip the lines and guarantee your favorites by pre-ordering!

  • Pre-Order Dates: September 25, 26, 27 & October 2, 3, 4

  • Pick-Up: All pickups are at our bakeshop at 3497 Holland Rd. Suite 102 VB 23452 at your selected time from 7am-1pm.

  • Pre-orders are highly recommended as many items will sell out in advance.

Public Pop-Up

We’ll also open the doors to everyone on two select dates—no pre-order required!

  • Dates: October 3 & 4

  • Offerings: A selection of fall pies, sweet treats, and grab-and-go savory favorites—first come, first served. We will sell out quick!

Why Pre-Order?

✨ Guarantees your must-have pies & soups!
✨ Easy pick-up with no waiting
✨ Baked fresh in just the right amount

Come stock up, cozy up, and celebrate fall flavors with us.

  • We do not offer coffee or sandwiches at this location.

*Last day to order is subject to change if we book up quicker than expected.

*We politely decline any requests for substitutions, alterations and/or additions.