Skip to main content
Celebrating Math & Merriment with Pi(e) Day at May’s!

Choose between 10 different whole pies or 4 Assorted Pie Packs- The Fruity Edition, The Dulce Edition or our Assorted packs if you want to get the most variety! (You can also purchase both The Assorted Pack #1 and #2 if you want to try a slice of all of the sweet pies!!)

Schedule your pre-order pickup!

Place your prepaid order for pickup on March 9th, March 13th or March 14th at our Oceanfront or Holland Location!

Due to high volume of orders, we are not accepting custom orders or orders for individual slices. Individual slices & Grab n’ go whole pies will be available in store first come first serve March 13th (Oceanfront & Norfolk only) and March 14th (Oceanfront, Norfolk and Holland) for all of your last minute purchasing needs! (Please note our Holland location is just a bakeshop used for pre-0rder pickups and extra pie purchases on those dates. We do not sell additional baked goods, food, drinks, etc at this location)

The Norfolk Location is not an option for any holiday pre-ordering because we do not have additional storage fridges to utilize on pickup days. However we will be offering pies by the slice and whole on 3/13 & 3/14.  

Spread the love with May’s Parlor Pies!

Place your order today for Pie Day pickup!

Authentic Tradition